PodSearch

Connected

513: I'm The TipKit Now

 

00:00:00   Hello and welcome to Connected episode 513. I am your keynote chairman, Stephen Hackett, and I am joined by annual chairman, Mike Hurley.

00:00:18   Hello, Stephen Hackett. It's a pleasure to be here and there. It's even more of a pleasure, oh my God, to introduce Federico Vittucci back to the show. I'm just so excited. I can't even speak.

00:00:29   Hello, Federico. Hello, I'm back. And if that's the effect I have on you, well, I'm very, very happy. You always tie my tongue Federico.

00:00:42   Everyone's back. I should say this episode is made possible by NetSuite, Fitbot, ExpressVPN and Zojou. I miss that. We're really struggling today.

00:00:53   But welcome back Federico. And the pro show this week, which is the longer ad-free version of the show that we do every single time, you came with some notes from vacation.

00:01:02   It was a real roller coaster of highs and lows of technology in 2024.

00:01:07   Mostly lows. Mostly lows. Mostly lows. But some realizations on everyone's part. And it's 20 minutes today, so if you want a good chunky pro show.

00:01:17   20 minutes of epiphanies, really. Realizations and takes. Yeah. Yeah. It was useful. It was a useful vacation to realize a few things.

00:01:28   But yeah, it's good to be here. I can't wait to do it, as somebody used to say.

00:01:36   Federico, how have you been celebrating performer month so far?

00:01:41   Mostly by being confused by the idea of performer month, because I feel like one day I was at the beach and I opened Mastodon, you know, as you do.

00:01:53   And I saw an announcement of performer month and I had no idea that Steven was planning this.

00:02:00   And I still kind of, I wanted to ask you, Steven, do you feel like maybe you're not enough of a busy person to also have this project?

00:02:11   I have been quite surprised at the length of these articles so far.

00:02:16   Follow up, Steven. Can I delegate some of my tasks to you? If you are so inclined.

00:02:22   I can't. I can't do any more. I am very busy.

00:02:25   Well, it seems like you have time for performer month. Yes, you definitely have an amount of time on your hands.

00:02:31   The trick of performer month was that I started in early July. I've been writing these for a while and most of them are written now.

00:02:38   So this is big year of Luigi energy right now, which lasted for two years. Like performer month has lasted for three months.

00:02:47   It's always performer month somewhere.

00:02:50   When we first talked about this, Mike, you asked me if I had bought any performers.

00:02:58   And at that point I had bought one for a photo. I have now bought a second one. I bought a 631 CD on eBay.

00:03:06   Of course. You see now, I feel like if we go back to the last episode, you were very much like, no, no, no, no, I'm not going to do that.

00:03:14   And now you've doubled your performer.

00:03:16   This will be, this should be the last one. It's like the only one I didn't have in this body style.

00:03:22   Uh huh. Sure. This is like, you know, that thing where it's like, if you take a grain of rice and you double a grain of rice and you, you doubled your amount of rice for every piece, like for every square on a chessboard that by the time you got to the end, it's more rice than there is on the planet.

00:03:39   Are you familiar with this idea? I don't know if this is true. This is what I imagined the performers situation is going to be.

00:03:44   I've seen like on Instagram, cause I'm too old for Tik TOK was like, do you want this banana or should I double it and give it to the next person? And then 30 seconds later, someone has said yes to 72 bananas.

00:03:55   Maybe it's like that.

00:03:59   I am so lost right now. I have no idea what you guys are saying.

00:04:02   Is that just my algorithm?

00:04:04   Starting with the rice, now with the bananas. What? You guys okay? Are you okay?

00:04:09   The Instagram bananas are doubling Federico. This is a big thing.

00:04:12   Sure.

00:04:13   I'm not sure what you guys are saying.

00:04:15   I'm just trying to figure out what you guys are saying.

00:04:17   I'm just trying to figure out what you guys are saying.

00:04:19   I'm just trying to figure out what you guys are saying.

00:04:21   I'm just trying to figure out what you guys are saying.

00:04:23   I'm just trying to figure out what you guys are saying.

00:04:25   I'm just trying to figure out what you guys are saying.

00:04:27   I'm just trying to figure out what you guys are saying.

00:04:29   I'm just trying to figure out what you guys are saying.

00:04:31   I'm just trying to figure out what you guys are saying.

00:04:33   I'm just trying to figure out what you guys are saying.

00:04:35   I'm just trying to figure out what you guys are saying.

00:04:37   I'm just trying to figure out what you guys are saying.

00:04:39   I'm just trying to figure out what you guys are saying.

00:04:41   I do. I do love beige.

00:04:43   Falling in love with old computers,

00:04:45   despite their historical failures.

00:04:47   Yeah, I do love beige computers now.

00:04:50   I have not written the conclusion to the series yet,

00:04:54   but there is something here.

00:04:57   If the idea was to get Macs into homes,

00:05:01   that was successful.

00:05:03   It cost Apple dearly in terms of brand reputation,

00:05:06   but do I love them?

00:05:08   I guess time will tell.

00:05:10   Hmm. Interesting.

00:05:12   Do you consider Perform All Month a success so far?

00:05:16   Yes. The traffic has been way better than I thought it would be.

00:05:20   Really? I mean, no offense, but really?

00:05:22   Yeah.

00:05:23   Okay. No offense.

00:05:25   It's been great.

00:05:26   Good.

00:05:27   And just the feedback.

00:05:29   People are like, "Oh, that was my first computer."

00:05:31   Or that part's been very cool.

00:05:35   The thing that I've been struck by when,

00:05:37   I'm sorry to say, I've been skimming this lot, of course,

00:05:39   I have been skimming them,

00:05:40   but it's more information than I want.

00:05:43   And that's the thing that I'm surprised about,

00:05:45   is how much information you have

00:05:47   considering you weren't really around at the time.

00:05:51   I can tell the amount of work that went into this.

00:05:53   I was alive.

00:05:54   Yeah, but you weren't like you are now, you know?

00:05:58   Sure.

00:05:59   You were a bit of a mere babe, you know?

00:06:01   Yeah.

00:06:02   And now you're an older babe.

00:06:03   Now I'm...

00:06:04   And you're writing about performance,

00:06:07   just like all babes would.

00:06:09   Yeah. It's my destiny.

00:06:11   I took a screenshot and I put it in our Notion document here,

00:06:15   but people can go to the page, the website,

00:06:19   which is called phytopixels.net,

00:06:21   and they can read more about performance.

00:06:23   It's a web page.

00:06:24   I'm sorry.

00:06:25   I don't know why I'm struggling so much today, but I am.

00:06:27   But I was really struck by the beauty

00:06:30   of the Macintosh Performer 600 logo,

00:06:33   just like the Apple logo

00:06:35   and their Macintosh Performer 600.

00:06:37   I don't know if you guys are aware of this or not,

00:06:40   but serifs like this are having a moment right now,

00:06:43   kind of stylistically.

00:06:44   Let's come back around again.

00:06:46   And just like right now,

00:06:47   all of the Macintosh Performer branding

00:06:50   would be very successful in 2024, I feel like.

00:06:54   That's all I have to say on that.

00:06:58   Well, I look forward to Cortex brand pivoting to serifs.

00:07:03   I actually spent a lot of time

00:07:05   over the last couple of weeks picking out serifs.

00:07:08   So there you go.

00:07:10   It's going to happen.

00:07:11   Performer month, let's go.

00:07:12   Listener Chris wrote in to Federico,

00:07:16   and I sat on this because Federico was gone,

00:07:19   but now you're back.

00:07:20   Oh, thank you.

00:07:21   So I cleared it out.

00:07:22   Like Federico, my favorite podcast app

00:07:24   for many years was Castro.

00:07:25   I stopped using it after their fiasco late last year

00:07:28   and moved on assuming it was dead.

00:07:30   I've never really been happy with my substitute

00:07:32   of pocket casts.

00:07:33   I was surprised and really pleased to learn

00:07:35   that Castro is back and better than ever.

00:07:37   My sincere thanks to Federico

00:07:39   for bringing this up recently.

00:07:40   My life is better now.

00:07:43   Wow.

00:07:44   Yeah, yeah.

00:07:45   Obviously I know that I make people's lives better.

00:07:48   All the time.

00:07:49   This doesn't surprise me.

00:07:51   Wow, you're so humble about it too,

00:07:53   which is really nice.

00:07:54   Yeah, yeah, yeah.

00:07:55   It did lead me to thinking of like,

00:07:57   this is the summer and getting into the fall.

00:07:59   Like there's new stock apps

00:08:01   and I kind of want to get everyone's temperature

00:08:03   and like, what do we do with the apps

00:08:05   that we use every day

00:08:06   when there's new versions of Apple's apps?

00:08:08   Like where kind of are we in that cycle right now?

00:08:12   So personally, I've been doing this,

00:08:20   like I've been thinking about this

00:08:21   for two categories of apps.

00:08:24   The first one was podcasts and the other one was mail.

00:08:28   And usually during the summer review season,

00:08:34   I try to, obviously I try to test all of the Apple defaults

00:08:39   as much as possible.

00:08:40   But specifically this time around,

00:08:42   I was thinking about mail and podcasts

00:08:44   because I was really dissatisfied

00:08:46   with both of the apps that I was using before.

00:08:50   And when WWDC came and I saw that huge update to Apple Mail

00:08:56   that made me really hopeful.

00:08:59   Unfortunately, podcasts did not introduce the feature

00:09:03   and the changes that I wanted to see.

00:09:06   Apple Podcasts still doesn't have any sort of audio effects

00:09:10   and I dislike the way that the queue works in Apple Podcasts.

00:09:16   So I knew that I couldn't use podcasts

00:09:19   and that I had to keep using a third-party app.

00:09:21   For Mail, I thought,

00:09:22   "Oh, I'm going to get reacquainted with Mail

00:09:26   because then I'm going to get the upgrade

00:09:28   later in the iOS 18 cycle with categorization

00:09:31   and that's going to be incredible."

00:09:33   Now, sadly, it seems like I won't be getting the Mail upgrade

00:09:39   because that's based on Apple Intelligence

00:09:42   and I will not have access to Apple Intelligence in Europe

00:09:46   in the near future.

00:09:48   Unless you use the Macintosh.

00:09:51   Unless I use the Macintosh, I guess, which I don't.

00:09:55   So, yeah.

00:09:57   It's half of your pad.

00:09:59   Well, yes.

00:10:02   You have-- Uh-oh. Hang on.

00:10:04   What's going on there?

00:10:06   Now it's the iPad pad. He's just two iPads.

00:10:09   He stuck them together.

00:10:11   Formulate your question carefully, Steven.

00:10:13   What do you want to know?

00:10:15   Did you ditch the Mac part of the Mac pad?

00:10:20   Well, no. It's not like I ditched it.

00:10:22   It's just that since I figured out--

00:10:24   When's the last time you used macOS?

00:10:26   [laughter]

00:10:28   I used it two days ago

00:10:30   because I needed to export a save

00:10:33   from the Dolphin emulator for a GameCube game.

00:10:37   As one does.

00:10:39   Okay, so he's not using it a lot then,

00:10:42   is I think what we can assess in this.

00:10:45   I am working on an article about this,

00:10:48   but since I figured out how to record podcasts

00:10:51   on the iPad Pro, as I'm doing right now

00:10:53   and as I've been doing for the past two months,

00:10:55   my usage of macOS has gone way down again.

00:10:59   Yeah. So anyway.

00:11:01   For mail, I'm looking for an email client again

00:11:06   because I had high hopes for Apple Mail.

00:11:10   I thought, "Oh, I'm going to use Apple Mail this summer.

00:11:12   I just need to hold tight with this version of Apple Mail,

00:11:15   and then it's going to get so much better with Apple Intelligence."

00:11:18   And then it wasn't because I'm in Europe.

00:11:22   So I'm once again using Spark right now,

00:11:26   and I don't love it, but like, you know,

00:11:31   I need to use something that separates my emails into categories.

00:11:35   Which it does a good job of.

00:11:37   It does a very, very good job of.

00:11:39   It's pretty good. And to be fair,

00:11:41   like, I think, Mike, over the years,

00:11:46   I think you've had plenty of good opinions.

00:11:49   Some of them better than others.

00:11:52   That's fair.

00:11:53   But over the years,

00:11:55   I have stuck with one particular opinion of yours

00:11:59   as words to live by, so to speak,

00:12:02   that all email apps are bad.

00:12:05   And this is something I remind myself

00:12:08   like you saying this sentence many years ago.

00:12:11   It's something that I think about to this day quite often.

00:12:14   And I'm thinking about it this week a lot.

00:12:17   I have a 2024 version of that opinion.

00:12:21   Okay.

00:12:23   Which is all email apps are bad because email is bad.

00:12:26   Mm-mm-mm-mm.

00:12:28   Like, inherently, there is not so much you can do with your email app

00:12:32   on top of what is already a bad thing, which is email.

00:12:36   Like, the system of email is just bad.

00:12:38   So, like, the bar is incredibly low.

00:12:41   The thing that I think is actually kind of heartbreaking

00:12:44   about this story is in using 18.1,

00:12:49   I provided that the categorization features are good enough,

00:12:55   I think I might switch to Apple Mail.

00:12:58   So I feel bad for you.

00:13:03   See, I have a different take on Apple Intelligence and Mail.

00:13:08   Okay.

00:13:09   I've been running 18.1.

00:13:11   It's on my phone and my iPad, and I'm not that impressed with it.

00:13:15   I don't feel like the summarization is all that useful.

00:13:20   And in several cases, it's not as bad as the example you mentioned

00:13:23   on Upgrade Mic where it made up a word and...

00:13:26   Bae.

00:13:27   Bae.

00:13:28   Or Voorhees' example where it kept calling him John Gruber,

00:13:32   which is hysterical.

00:13:34   But I just...

00:13:36   I don't feel like it's added a lot of value for me.

00:13:42   And I'm a MimeStream user on the Mac,

00:13:44   and I want to use MimeStream on iOS and iPadOS when it comes out.

00:13:48   And, like, I don't know if Apple Intelligence would be enough

00:13:50   to sway me to stay in Apple Mail once that time comes.

00:13:54   I mean, you're using...

00:13:58   You're looking at the previews in the inbox, right?

00:14:00   Yeah.

00:14:01   Okay.

00:14:02   Because that's what I like specifically.

00:14:04   Yeah, yeah, yeah.

00:14:05   You can also get it at the top of a message.

00:14:07   That, in the inbox, is better.

00:14:09   They're different, which is wild.

00:14:11   They're different summaries.

00:14:12   Yeah, what's going on there?

00:14:14   They're completely different.

00:14:16   I don't know why that is.

00:14:17   I think potentially the ones in the inbox,

00:14:20   they're trying to be more succinct.

00:14:22   I think so.

00:14:23   Because you only have, like, a couple of lines.

00:14:26   But, like, I like it.

00:14:27   You know, I get any kind of marketing messages that I get,

00:14:32   it becomes easier to filter them.

00:14:34   You know, like, this one has a coupon code in it,

00:14:37   and this one's just telling you about a thing.

00:14:39   Like, I think it's good.

00:14:40   I like it.

00:14:41   But I think it is only really a feature

00:14:44   that appeals to a certain type of email user,

00:14:47   and potentially we are different types of email users.

00:14:49   Yeah, maybe.

00:14:51   We don't need to talk about Apple Intelligence again.

00:14:55   Ever?

00:14:56   Well, not now, because Chris wanted to know about podcasts.

00:15:00   Oh, yeah. Sorry, Chris.

00:15:02   We got distracted.

00:15:04   And so I talked about mail.

00:15:07   When it comes to podcasts,

00:15:09   I gave Overcast a try for the past couple of weeks.

00:15:14   And so I went back to Castro in the end

00:15:20   because of a very particular feature.

00:15:24   I got to say, I really like the audio quality of Overcast.

00:15:29   I think it's the best one.

00:15:31   The Smart Speed, the Volume Boost.

00:15:34   I think it's -- If you only judge the audio effects,

00:15:38   it is the best version of those audio effects.

00:15:42   It's the original one, and it's still the best one.

00:15:45   But there's two things I dislike about Overcast,

00:15:50   and that's why I went back to Castro.

00:15:53   The first one is the now plain screen design.

00:15:59   I like parts of it, and other parts of it,

00:16:02   I find kind of disorienting still.

00:16:05   I feel like sometimes I'm double-checking,

00:16:09   like, "Where am I supposed to click again?"

00:16:12   I don't know.

00:16:13   Something about it is not sticking with me.

00:16:16   But that's not a huge deal.

00:16:18   What was a deal-breaker for me is how the Q system works.

00:16:22   And maybe Castro spoiled me,

00:16:26   but here's how I like to listen to my podcasts.

00:16:30   I like to see a list of all episodes.

00:16:33   Like, here's all the latest episodes that have come out

00:16:36   from the shows you're subscribed to.

00:16:38   I like to tap on one and add it to my Q.

00:16:42   And from that all-episodes view,

00:16:46   the episode can either go away, as it does with Castro,

00:16:50   or it can stay there.

00:16:52   But if it stays there, it needs to tell me,

00:16:55   I need to have some kind of indicator that tells me,

00:16:58   "Hey, this episode, you have already queued.

00:17:01   It's already somewhere in your queue."

00:17:04   For the past two weeks with Overcast,

00:17:07   I spent most of my time interacting with the app,

00:17:10   looking at the all-episodes view and thinking,

00:17:13   "Have I queued this episode already or not?"

00:17:16   And I know you can tap it,

00:17:18   and then you gotta click on the ellipsis button.

00:17:21   And when you do, if the episode has already been queued,

00:17:25   the Add to Queue button will be slightly grayed out.

00:17:30   And, you know, that's three taps to understand something

00:17:34   that should be explained to the user at a glance.

00:17:37   - I would like to give you a tip.

00:17:39   You don't have to use it if you've already decided.

00:17:41   But in the new redesign,

00:17:45   there is a new option called Move to Queue.

00:17:49   - Where? - That does what you want.

00:17:51   - Where?

00:17:53   - So when you're on an episode

00:17:55   and you hit, like, the three-dot icon thing,

00:17:59   there is Add to and Move to.

00:18:02   If you select Move to and then Queue,

00:18:05   the next time you press the three-dot icon,

00:18:08   it creates a shortcut button

00:18:10   that's at the top of the context thing.

00:18:15   - I don't know.

00:18:20   But I really like how the queue works in Castro.

00:18:23   - I mean, it's the originator of that style.

00:18:25   - Yeah. - And I do, too.

00:18:27   I have always preferred the way that the queue works in Castro

00:18:30   'cause just the UI was built around that system,

00:18:33   and that's where I came to really love that system.

00:18:36   But the general listening experience of Overcast I prefer,

00:18:42   and so I've kind of just stuck with it.

00:18:46   - So I completely missed the existence of this Move to Queue button.

00:18:53   - Yeah. - This is interesting.

00:18:55   - Yeah, it's new and didn't really get a lot of--

00:18:58   like, a lot of time people mentioned it.

00:19:00   - It's a new feature, right?

00:19:02   It's a new thing. - With the redesign.

00:19:05   It came with the redesign.

00:19:07   - Huh. Interesting. Interesting.

00:19:10   Well, maybe then, Chris,

00:19:13   maybe I'll have to try Overcast again

00:19:15   because I completely missed.

00:19:17   I saw somewhere on Threads somebody--

00:19:21   this was, like, an algorithmically recommended post to me.

00:19:24   - I think we've got this post.

00:19:26   - Somebody's saying, "I find the new Overcast confusing.

00:19:31   "Maybe there should be some kind of walkthrough

00:19:33   "or some kind of onboarding experience

00:19:35   "that explains how things moved, where things are."

00:19:38   And I think that's probably a good idea.

00:19:40   Like, I don't know, maybe there's that--

00:19:44   what's it called on iOS? That framework, Tipkit.

00:19:46   - Tipkit. - That allows you to, like--

00:19:48   - Tipkit. - introduce--

00:19:50   Tipkit-- introduce features to customers,

00:19:53   like, maybe even gradually.

00:19:55   Like, "Hey, this thing is now here,

00:19:57   "and this thing has moved there."

00:19:59   And I've seen it used in--

00:20:01   like, those alerts used in a bunch of apps,

00:20:03   and they're usually pretty effective.

00:20:05   So, yeah.

00:20:07   Maybe I'll have to try Overcast again

00:20:09   because thank you for the tip, Mike.

00:20:13   - It's a Mike tip. - It's a Mike tip.

00:20:15   - Yeah. - Mm-hmm.

00:20:16   - Am I the only one who doesn't use the queue?

00:20:18   Like, in Overcast, I have--

00:20:20   well, I have four playlists because three of them--

00:20:22   - How do you even leave? Like, how?

00:20:24   - So here's what I do.

00:20:26   I have one playlist called Current.

00:20:28   I also have Download It in Progress and Starred

00:20:30   because you can't remove his built-in playlist,

00:20:33   which I find frustrating.

00:20:35   - You can. Look at me.

00:20:37   I'm just like-- - What? No, where?

00:20:39   - I'm the guy now.

00:20:40   So if you go to Settings--

00:20:42   - Oh, God. - If you go to Settings,

00:20:43   you go to Customize Home Screen,

00:20:45   and you can turn off Download It in Progress and Starred.

00:20:48   - Wow. Okay, well, I have that done now.

00:20:50   So now I have one playlist called Current.

00:20:52   - I'm the Tipkit.

00:20:54   - And-- - Look at me.

00:20:55   I'm the Tipkit now. - All that does is pull in

00:20:58   episodes that I have downloaded,

00:21:01   which are all the new ones because it all just downloads now.

00:21:03   So I just go in there-- - What order do you listen

00:21:05   to podcasts in? You just like randomly--

00:21:07   - I just pick the one I want to listen to.

00:21:09   - What? - I only have four episodes

00:21:11   in here right now. It's no big deal.

00:21:13   - What? - Yeah.

00:21:14   - That's weird. - I'm on top of my stuff.

00:21:16   What are you--oh, animals.

00:21:18   - I know. I have, like, a backlog of things,

00:21:20   and I might want to listen to something from that at some point.

00:21:22   - I rarely do that, and if I did,

00:21:24   they would just be in the list, and I'd pick what I want.

00:21:27   - I don't need a queue. - Also, what I really like

00:21:29   about Castro, in the queue,

00:21:32   so you can either view your queue by episodes

00:21:35   or you can view your queue by shows,

00:21:38   and that's an excellent way to see, for example,

00:21:40   okay, let me see how many besties episode

00:21:43   episodes I have queued. - Yeah, that's nice.

00:21:45   - That's very nice. - Yeah, that's nice.

00:21:47   - So I don't know. But, yeah, for me, it comes down,

00:21:49   you know, between Castro and Overcast right now.

00:21:52   - I will say, though, like, in the--

00:21:56   I'm looking at Castro now.

00:21:58   It feels old now, like, in the way

00:22:01   that Overcast is feeling old to me.

00:22:03   Like, this--the app is very pretty,

00:22:07   but it is--

00:22:09   - It's got some, like, iOS 7 in it in places.

00:22:12   - It's over time, and for me,

00:22:16   I want--honestly, I would like something in between,

00:22:19   visually, of these two applications,

00:22:22   because I feel like Overcast doesn't have

00:22:24   as much personality as it used to,

00:22:26   but Castro has too much for me.

00:22:30   - Yeah, so, podcasts.

00:22:33   - Thanks, Chris.

00:22:36   - This episode of "Connected" is brought to you by NetSuite.

00:22:39   Quick math--the less your business spends on operations,

00:22:42   multiple systems, and delivering your product or service,

00:22:45   the more margin you have and the more money you get to keep.

00:22:48   But with higher expenses on materials, employees,

00:22:51   distribution, and borrowing, everything costs more now.

00:22:55   So to reduce cost and headaches,

00:22:57   smart businesses are moving to NetSuite by Oracle.

00:23:01   NetSuite is the number one cloud financial system

00:23:04   bringing accounting, financial management, inventory,

00:23:07   and HR into one platform and one source of truth.

00:23:10   With NetSuite, you reduce IT costs

00:23:13   because NetSuite lives in the cloud

00:23:15   with no hardware required and is accessed from anywhere.

00:23:18   You cut the cost of maintaining multiple systems

00:23:21   because you have one unified business management suite.

00:23:24   You improve efficiency by bringing

00:23:26   all your major businesses' processes into one platform,

00:23:30   slashing manual tasks and errors.

00:23:32   Over 37,000 companies have already made the move,

00:23:35   so do the math and see how you'll profit with NetSuite.

00:23:39   Boosting business performance

00:23:41   isn't necessarily a big, complicated thing.

00:23:44   Take this idea of having multiple processes

00:23:46   across multiple systems.

00:23:48   You have people moving data in and out,

00:23:50   and it can be really time-consuming and error-prone.

00:23:53   And with NetSuite's tools, you can get rid of all that work.

00:23:57   By popular demand, they've extended their

00:23:59   one-of-a-kind flexible financing program for a few more weeks.

00:24:03   So head on over to netsuite.com/connected.

00:24:06   That's N-E-T-S-U-I-T-E.

00:24:09   netsuite.com/connected.

00:24:12   Our thanks to NetSuite for their support of the show

00:24:15   and all of Relay.

00:24:17   Got some sad news. SuperDrive...

00:24:21   -Oh. -...is gone.

00:24:23   -That's pretty good. -That's the little thing.

00:24:27   -That was good. -Yeah, it's pretty good

00:24:29   for a podcaster's mouth, you know? Good job.

00:24:32   My tongue is no longer tied.

00:24:34   -Yeah, obviously. -It's like a bugle sound.

00:24:36   Yeah.

00:24:38   I still have one, and I still use it.

00:24:41   So it's a good accessory, you know?

00:24:45   Man, CDs and DVDs were a good format.

00:24:49   I'm just gonna say it, you know?

00:24:51   -Okay. -Courage.

00:24:53   You know?

00:24:55   It's good for-- Like, it was a good--

00:24:57   Like, remember the PlayStation 1 CDs,

00:25:01   and they were black? Those were cool.

00:25:03   -Yeah. Super cool. -You know?

00:25:05   Nothing will ever be cooler to meet in the GameCube CDs, though.

00:25:08   -The little ones? -Ah, the little ones.

00:25:10   What's that? Mini DVD?

00:25:12   I don't even know what format they were.

00:25:14   -They're just GameCube. -I think it was Mini DVD, yeah.

00:25:16   Did anybody else use them?

00:25:18   I think it was, like, Nintendo and some promotional materials.

00:25:22   Like, that was the end of it.

00:25:24   Wasn't the Mini DVD, like, a Panasonic format or something?

00:25:27   And that's why Panasonic made a specific version

00:25:30   of the GameCube called the iQ, just for China?

00:25:33   Am I making this up?

00:25:35   -No, I believe you. -I don't think I am.

00:25:37   I believe you.

00:25:39   -No, Nintendo-- -No, you believe me.

00:25:41   Okay, I'm on the Mini DVD Wikipedia page.

00:25:43   This is Nintendo used a very similar disc-based format

00:25:47   for the GameCube, called the GameCube Game Disc.

00:25:51   -DOL-006. -Of course.

00:25:55   It was their own medium.

00:25:57   That sounds about right.

00:25:59   It's gonna look like it's a standard, but it won't be.

00:26:03   -Love Nintendo. -But anyways,

00:26:05   CDs and DVDs were cool.

00:26:08   I have these memories,

00:26:11   which I realize what I'm about to say

00:26:14   is probably something very Italian,

00:26:16   and I'm gonna try my best at contextualizing this

00:26:19   and explaining this to you both,

00:26:21   because I think you guys have no idea what I'm referring to.

00:26:25   When I was a kid--

00:26:27   So we're talking mid-'90s, mid-to-late '90s.

00:26:34   PlayStation 1 was huge in Italy,

00:26:37   just obviously elsewhere, too.

00:26:39   But PlayStation 1 piracy was also pretty wild.

00:26:45   Everybody, including me,

00:26:47   everybody had a modded PlayStation 1.

00:26:50   Like, everybody had one with the mod chip.

00:26:53   And it was pretty like--

00:26:54   People who used to mod PlayStation 1s

00:26:57   were pretty like...

00:26:59   Like, even--

00:27:00   They weren't trying to make a secret about it.

00:27:03   Like, you could actually go to a store in the mid-'90s

00:27:06   and pay, like, pretty much in the open.

00:27:09   Like, it wasn't shady or anything.

00:27:11   Like, you would go to a store and pay

00:27:13   and get a receipt for a modded PS1.

00:27:16   And at the same time, obviously, mid-'90s, mid-to-late '90s,

00:27:22   music piracy was also pretty, you know, remarkable

00:27:26   in the sense that it was everywhere.

00:27:28   And CDs were the format at the time.

00:27:31   And so in Italy, we used to have these--

00:27:35   Especially in beach locations,

00:27:39   these street cellars for pirated CDs

00:27:44   for both music and PlayStation 1 video games.

00:27:48   And I have these memories of these guys

00:27:53   with these towels on the street or on the beach,

00:27:57   absolutely filled with hundreds of pirated copies

00:28:03   of music albums and PlayStation 1 games.

00:28:06   And, like, I think that's where my love

00:28:10   for the CD format comes from.

00:28:13   Also because those street cellars

00:28:17   with those pirated PlayStation 1 games,

00:28:20   I don't know, obviously,

00:28:22   who was behind that whole operation, right?

00:28:27   But those games, it was--

00:28:31   Like, the paradox of that was that you could

00:28:34   more easily find a rare game as a pirated copy

00:28:40   than by purchasing it via official channels.

00:28:44   For example, I remember finding

00:28:48   a Japanese copy of Dragon Ball Legends,

00:28:51   which is a pretty forgotten game for the PlayStation 1,

00:28:55   via one of these street cellars

00:28:58   sometime in the late '90s,

00:29:00   a game that I tried so many times

00:29:02   via my video game store friend to acquire legally,

00:29:06   and eventually I found a pirated copy

00:29:09   just in the middle of the street

00:29:11   for, like, five euros or something.

00:29:13   So, yeah, all this to say,

00:29:15   I have many memories when it comes to CDs and DVDs,

00:29:18   more so with CDs, I guess,

00:29:20   and the SuperDrive is a good accessory

00:29:23   that I used to digitize all of my legally purchased,

00:29:29   eventually when I had money, music collection,

00:29:32   and I'm sad that it's going away, but I understand why.

00:29:36   But CDs are cool, man,

00:29:38   and, you know, it's a good format.

00:29:40   I have a SuperDrive.

00:29:42   I've only ever used it to make CDs for family funerals.

00:29:46   Oh, geez.

00:29:48   That's my addition.

00:29:50   Okay.

00:29:51   'Cause, you know, like, you need music

00:29:53   at the funeral or whatever.

00:29:55   Sure.

00:29:56   And everyone looks to me, and they're like, "Make a CD."

00:29:58   I was like, "All right, I'll go buy a SuperDrive."

00:30:02   I bought two SuperDrives for this purpose

00:30:04   'cause one of them broke.

00:30:06   So I am currently one for one on SuperDrives to CDs burned.

00:30:13   I have made two CDs, two SuperDrives,

00:30:16   so it's all going great over here, but now no longer,

00:30:19   so hopefully no one in my family dies anymore

00:30:22   because I can't make the CDs maybe.

00:30:24   I probably have a SuperDrive somewhere,

00:30:26   but I don't know where it is,

00:30:27   but I'm just gonna assume it's broken.

00:30:29   Okay.

00:30:30   If you want to learn a lot about the SuperDrive history,

00:30:33   I got a link for you in the show notes.

00:30:34   Emergency Apple history blogging the other day.

00:30:37   Yeah, yeah.

00:30:38   Oh, is this new?

00:30:39   You hadn't already written this?

00:30:40   Nope.

00:30:42   Huh.

00:30:43   Banged it out the other day.

00:30:44   Oh, so you also have time for the SuperDrive.

00:30:47   [laughs]

00:30:48   You took a detour from performer month.

00:30:50   No, I don't, and I don't really understand you,

00:30:54   and you also have a family, you have three kids,

00:30:56   a dog and a cat, if I'm not mistaken.

00:30:59   And a fish.

00:31:00   And a snake.

00:31:01   A snake.

00:31:02   And a fish.

00:31:03   A bunch of projects.

00:31:05   You just did a big show in London.

00:31:08   You're doing a podcast.

00:31:10   Can you teach me productivity?

00:31:11   Here's the thing.

00:31:12   Here's what has happened to me this year.

00:31:14   It's the first year in three years I didn't do a Kickstarter.

00:31:17   Oh, I thought you were gonna say it's cocaine,

00:31:20   but okay, sure.

00:31:21   It's the first year I started doing drugs.

00:31:23   It's the first year of drugs.

00:31:24   And now I am just so, so, so productive.

00:31:29   No, but that was a very busy project.

00:31:34   Right now I'd be proofing the final thing,

00:31:37   getting ready to go to the printer,

00:31:39   and Kickstarter would be ending, and all that's just gone.

00:31:42   And it's kinda nice.

00:31:44   I will say performer month is not gonna earn the revenue

00:31:47   the calendar did.

00:31:48   [laughs]

00:31:49   It's just not as lucrative.

00:31:51   If you want to sponsor performer month, get in touch.

00:31:55   [laughs]

00:31:56   What are your rights?

00:31:58   Whatever the calendar made, divided by 18 blog posts.

00:32:02   Geez.

00:32:03   Wow.

00:32:04   Performer month.

00:32:05   Those CPMs, man.

00:32:07   That's right.

00:32:08   Oh, the base is pretty close to gold.

00:32:09   Think about it.

00:32:10   That's true.

00:32:11   So your productivity secret is not doing Kickstarter anymore?

00:32:16   It's not doing Kickstarter, yeah.

00:32:17   But what if I've never done Kickstarters?

00:32:20   Well, that's the thing.

00:32:21   You have to do one.

00:32:22   No, you've gotta start.

00:32:23   Yeah, you gotta start and then stop.

00:32:25   Yeah.

00:32:26   You've gotta be super busy, like to a point where it's probably not healthy, and then

00:32:32   stop that, and then it's fine.

00:32:35   Federico, just stop doing the iOS review.

00:32:38   Exactly.

00:32:39   That's your analog.

00:32:40   If you just stop doing the iOS review, imagine how much time you'd have to write about performers.

00:32:45   Well, that's covered.

00:32:46   You can do something else.

00:32:48   No, write about performers.

00:32:49   I want performer versus performer.

00:32:51   Jeweling performers.

00:32:52   Oh my God.

00:32:53   I'm gonna write articles about computers that I don't even know.

00:32:55   What they are.

00:32:56   Speaking of which, speaking of which, tell us about the Lenovo ThinkBook Plus Hybrid.

00:33:06   Look, you gotta respect Lenovo.

00:33:08   Okay.

00:33:09   They're one of my favorite companies.

00:33:11   The Lenovo Lee Jung Go.

00:33:13   It's one of my favorite gaming handles.

00:33:15   But this device, the ThinkBook Plus Hybrid.

00:33:19   So this is a China only product for now.

00:33:21   And I think.

00:33:22   Until you get one, and there'll be one in Italy.

00:33:24   It sounds ridiculous, but I think they're onto something.

00:33:27   So the idea here is the following.

00:33:30   Imagine the MacPad, but as an official product.

00:33:34   So you have an Android tablet.

00:33:36   It's a 14 inch Android tablet that runs Android.

00:33:40   You can use it as a tablet.

00:33:42   It's pretty regular device.

00:33:44   It's just an Android tablet.

00:33:46   The secret is at the bottom of the tablet.

00:33:49   The same accessory, the same computer also comes with a keyboard.

00:33:54   But there's a catch.

00:33:55   The keyboard is actually a computer.

00:33:57   Just like, for example, my severed half of a MacBook is a computer.

00:34:04   So when you dock the tablet on top of the keyboard, it changes the operating system.

00:34:13   So when you dock it, now you're using Windows.

00:34:16   Because in the keyboard, there's a whole PC.

00:34:19   And that's the idea.

00:34:20   So there's a Snapdragon 8 Gen 1 in the tablet, which is not, you know, not the most recent chip for a tablet.

00:34:28   But it's good enough, I guess.

00:34:30   But the keyboard/laptop comes with a Meteor Lake Intel processor.

00:34:36   And when you dock the tablet, the tablet becomes a screen for the PC that's inside the keyboard.

00:34:42   And I gotta say, I kind of love the idea.

00:34:48   And I would pay serious money for an Apple version of this.

00:34:51   You know what I mean?

00:34:52   You know?

00:34:53   Now, I don't know.

00:34:55   Like, I don't know anybody who uses this product.

00:34:58   It seems like it was just announced.

00:35:01   It's not even clear if this thing will ever come to Europe or the United States.

00:35:06   But I think it's something interesting, right?

00:35:09   That you can--and it's what I've always wanted.

00:35:12   And it's what we've been talking about for so long now.

00:35:15   Like, wouldn't it be cool if you had a computer and you could rip off the display and use it as a tablet?

00:35:20   And then when you dock it again, you're using the computer's operating system again.

00:35:23   I still think the idea is cool and great, actually.

00:35:28   But Apple seems to disagree, obviously.

00:35:30   Because they're making separate products.

00:35:32   But still, in Windows land--in Windows and Android land, people are thinking about this.

00:35:38   And companies are building these types of devices.

00:35:41   Now, too bad that I really dislike Android and Windows.

00:35:44   So there's that.

00:35:46   Yeah.

00:35:47   It is really weird to have one computer that has two operating systems and I'm assuming shares none of the same files.

00:35:55   It is.

00:35:56   And, you know, imagine if Apple did it, though.

00:35:58   You know, they could find ways to make the experience so much nicer.

00:36:05   I would argue that if you just consider the nice factor, you know, just how nice it is to use an operating system,

00:36:14   iPadOS alone is nicer than Windows and Android combined.

00:36:20   But, you know.

00:36:22   Still, the Think Boot+ hybrid, it's a real product from Lenovo shipping at some point in China.

00:36:30   This episode of Connected is brought to you by Fitbod.

00:36:33   When you want to change your fitness level, it can be hard to know where to start.

00:36:37   That's why I'm pleased to let you know that Fitbod is an easy and affordable way to build a fitness plan that's just for you.

00:36:43   Everyone's fitness path is different, which is why Fitbod uses data to make sure they customize things exactly to suit you.

00:36:50   Adapting as you improve so each workout will be challenging, pushing you to make the progress you want.

00:36:56   Superior results are achieved when a workout program is tailored to your unique body, experience, environment, and goals,

00:37:03   which are all stored in your Fitbod gym profile.

00:37:07   Fitbod tracks your muscle recovery so you can avoid burnout and keep up your momentum.

00:37:12   And it builds your best possible workout by combining AI with exercise science.

00:37:17   They've analyzed billions of data points that have been fine-tuned by certified personal trainers.

00:37:23   And you can be sure you're learning new movements the right way thanks to more than a thousand in-app demonstration videos.

00:37:30   Muscles improve while working in concert with the entire system, so overworking some muscles while underworking others can negatively impact results.

00:37:39   That's why Fitbod tracks muscle fatigue and recovery to design a well-balanced workout routine,

00:37:45   which also means you'll never get bored as the app mixes up your workouts with new exercises, rep schemes, supersets, and circuits.

00:37:53   You can stay informed with your progress thanks to Fitbod's tracking charts, weekly reports, and sharing cards,

00:37:59   letting you keep track of your achievements and personal bests and then share them with friends and family.

00:38:05   It also integrates with your Apple Watch, Wear OS smartwatches, and apps like Strava, Fitbit, and Apple Health.

00:38:12   I mentioned the videos in the app that show you the workouts. That's one of my favorite parts about Fitbod.

00:38:17   You know, you just see the name of an exercise or maybe a photo. It doesn't tell the whole story.

00:38:21   And with these videos, and many of them have multiple angles, you can really see what you're supposed to do.

00:38:27   Personalized training of this quality can be expensive, but Fitbod is just $12.99 a month or $79.99 a year.

00:38:35   But you can get 25% off your membership by signing up at fitbod.me/connected.

00:38:43   So go there now and get your customized fitness plan at fitbod.me/connected.

00:38:48   That's F-I-T-B-O-D. Fitbod.me/connected.

00:38:55   Our thanks to Fitbod for the support of the show.

00:38:59   So I also wanted to talk about a major app update to one of my favorite iOS and iPadOS apps, which is Goodlinks.

00:39:09   Now, I have been, just like I've been between podcast clients, I've also been in between Read Later apps.

00:39:16   Lately, I've been in between this very app, Goodlinks, because of version two that just came out, and Readwise Reader.

00:39:24   Same, actually.

00:39:26   Yeah, yeah. So Readwise Reader has the advantage of also being able to receive your newsletters, for example,

00:39:33   and has a pretty good text parser and allows you to put together these saved searches based on custom filters, which is pretty cool.

00:39:42   But it also has a bunch of AI stuff that makes me a little, "Eh, you know."

00:39:47   On the other hand, Goodlinks is an excellent native experience for Apple platforms.

00:39:54   And version two just came out with a major addition, which is Highlights and Notes.

00:39:59   So finally, in addition to saving your links for later in Goodlinks, and Goodlinks, I gotta say, I think,

00:40:06   of all the Read Later apps that I've tried, I think Goodlinks is on par with Safari Reader in terms of extracting text from web articles.

00:40:15   The parser is better than Readwise Reader, is better than Matter is another app.

00:40:21   Excellent text parser. It even lets you log into paywalled websites.

00:40:27   So for example, my six or seven websites, I can log into the Goodlinks settings to make sure that I can save their paywalled content.

00:40:37   It's a really nice feature.

00:40:39   And now you can highlight. As you read, you can save your highlights, you can choose between multiple colors.

00:40:45   And even better than that, which is why I'm so stuck between choosing these two apps,

00:40:52   those highlights you can automate with shortcuts.

00:40:55   So you can export all of your highlights, your annotations, you can automate the entire process.

00:41:02   I built a shortcut that allows me, for example, to take all of my highlights from an article

00:41:07   and put together different variables for the article title, the name of the author, the URL,

00:41:15   and basically go from an article that I'm reading and highlighting to a draft for a linked post on Mac Stories,

00:41:22   with the highlights becoming block quotes that I can use in the article.

00:41:26   Things like that. This is what Goodlinks is excellent at.

00:41:30   And also, it's very native and it supports shortcuts, widgets in multiple sizes, dynamic type for custom text sizes,

00:41:42   you can install custom fonts.

00:41:45   All these platform features, Goodlinks is usually excellent at respecting them and implementing them in a really nice way.

00:41:53   So I don't know, I just wanted to point people to this update to Goodlinks 2,

00:41:58   which also comes with a new business model.

00:42:01   So there's a new subscription, but like I think I've seen this model before in the Dew app,

00:42:08   if you subscribe for a year of updates, you're going to keep those features,

00:42:15   which I think is a really reasonable way to go about this.

00:42:19   More specifically, you can, and I'm just double-checking the amount here.

00:42:25   So the base application is like $10 on the App Store.

00:42:30   You can purchase Goodlinks Premium for $5 and you will get updates for one year.

00:42:37   And even if you cancel your subscription after that, you'll still retain all the features released within that year that you paid for.

00:42:45   And if you purchase Goodlinks in the 12 months prior to the version 2 release,

00:42:51   you will get the highlighting and not taking features for free.

00:42:54   So I think it's a really nice way to go about this rollout.

00:42:57   I have seen no complaints. Usually there's always that guy, when we post something about Mac stories,

00:43:05   an app that is switching to a subscription that is always like Frank or something that sends us an email.

00:43:10   It's like, "Oh, this app is wrong."

00:43:13   It's usually like Frank or some guy named Corey or something.

00:43:18   It's like, you know what I'm talking about. It's that person.

00:43:25   It's like, "Oh, I can't believe your guys are supporting a developer with this ethics."

00:43:33   And it's like, "Okay, Corey, sure."

00:43:35   But I've seen no Frank and no Corey this time, which is usually a pretty good sign.

00:43:40   Maybe Frank or Corey just don't have links.

00:43:46   Yeah, maybe they're using Instapaper or something.

00:43:50   They don't have six or seven links.

00:43:52   I used Goodlinks for a long, long time and switched to Readwise Reader

00:43:59   and partially because of the Boox Poma because there's an Android version as well,

00:44:03   and I could save things to that, read it later on the eating thing.

00:44:07   But I do miss Goodlinks.

00:44:10   Readwise Reader is good, but I don't use any of their RSS stuff.

00:44:16   It's also an RSS client. I don't use any of that stuff.

00:44:19   And it's way more, shockingly more expensive than Goodlinks is.

00:44:24   So I may end up going back and having my read it later stuff on the Boox.

00:44:31   Can I say something that could potentially be interpreted the wrong way,

00:44:35   but I actually mean no.

00:44:36   Yes.

00:44:37   Okay, so why--we were talking about podcasts, now we're talking about reader apps.

00:44:43   Why do we have to be monogamists with the apps that we use?

00:44:49   This is something that I think about a lot, actually.

00:44:52   Like, oh, I need to use one.

00:44:55   And very so often I find myself thinking, oh, but I like to use this, but I also like to use that.

00:45:04   And I feel like the time and the energy that I spend about thinking about what is the best

00:45:13   and what is the one that I should use is actually time that could go into using both of them

00:45:19   without thinking about it anymore.

00:45:21   Does that make sense?

00:45:23   Well, I guess part of the thing is if you're trying to use multiple,

00:45:27   do you not end up just duplicating everything?

00:45:30   It becomes messy, right?

00:45:32   Do you?

00:45:33   I don't know. You tell me.

00:45:35   I don't know. You tell me.

00:45:39   No, you tell me.

00:45:40   This is why I actually like RSS apps and email apps to a point,

00:45:46   because there is a service that you authenticate with the application.

00:45:51   And so what I like, I can try as many RSS apps as I want and I stay in sync, right?

00:45:57   That's the benefit of that kind of underlying system that I like for trying out new applications.

00:46:05   For example, trying out a new to-do app is complicated.

00:46:08   However, what I will say, I am a person. I use four to-do apps.

00:46:12   So I actively use them all and I'm happy.

00:46:15   You are polyamorous with your apps.

00:46:18   But people have made fun of me for years, Federico, I think including you,

00:46:21   when we've done our roasts about why do you use so many apps with checkmarks on them.

00:46:25   Hey, look, I'm a change person.

00:46:27   You know what? That's the growth element, right?

00:46:29   Yeah. It's one of my many qualities, as we have established.

00:46:34   Or at least, I have.

00:46:36   Stephen, thoughts on monogamy?

00:46:39   Do you have them?

00:46:42   Generally in favor.

00:46:44   So with Good Links, I jumped through Raindrop because I wanted my archive of 14,000 links in Readwise Reader,

00:46:54   like in the archive.

00:46:56   Boy, it was real unhappy about importing those, but it eventually did it.

00:47:00   So there is a cost to some of these things.

00:47:04   There is a cost.

00:47:06   Yes, there is a cost, that's for sure.

00:47:09   And I think also the argument could be, well, it's easy for you to say that you want to use multiple services

00:47:17   because you have maybe the disposable income to subscribe to multiple services, and I totally get that.

00:47:23   I think the financial argument is probably the strongest argument in favor of, well, you've got to pick one.

00:47:32   Because I cannot pay for, say, both Apple Music and Spotify, or I cannot pay for both Readwise and Raindrop.

00:47:42   So that I totally get, if that's the point.

00:47:46   But if saying, well, I don't mind spending 10 bucks on this and 10 bucks on that,

00:47:52   because I spend that money on, I don't know, coffee or Starbucks or whatever, anyway.

00:47:58   Then I think it's, there's, I don't know, I am thinking about this topic of, in our community specifically,

00:48:08   we tend to gravitate toward picking one app and one device.

00:48:16   Whereas that's something that doesn't necessarily happen in other communities, like, for example, video games.

00:48:24   Just one that comes to mind.

00:48:27   But specifically for the Apple community, I think there's this, I don't know, maybe it's a Steve Jobs thing or something.

00:48:34   There's this heritage of, well, you have to use one device and one app to rule them all.

00:48:42   And I don't know, maybe there's room for more flexibility there.

00:48:47   You know the thing that made me think about this?

00:48:50   Was actually the Journal app.

00:48:54   Because of the suggestions coming from multiple data sources.

00:49:00   And now, actually, in iOS 18, Journal can gather those media suggestions from different podcast apps and different music apps.

00:49:09   Oh, good, I didn't know that. That passed me by, and that's really good news.

00:49:14   It should have been doing that for a long time, so I'm happy that it can do that now.

00:49:17   And so that idea of, like, here you have one single quote-unquote "database" journal that can gather those recommendations from multiple places,

00:49:26   I think it's an interesting idea.

00:49:29   But I don't know, good links too.

00:49:31   It's a great update and you should go check it out, especially because of the highlights, and if you're a shortcuts person, because of shortcuts.

00:49:39   According to Mark Gurman, Apple is looking to develop a plastic-based Apple Watch SE that is "more kid-friendly" with potentially "a better array of colors".

00:49:51   There's an interesting article about this from Wes Davis on The Verge, and Wes is talking about, like,

00:49:59   "Oh, maybe this could be just a more fun Apple Watch to wear, but if you like the things that are most recent, it's still going to be an SE,

00:50:08   so it's going to be held back from whatever other updates there are to the Apple Watch line."

00:50:13   But I think, Stephen, you put this in the show notes, and I wasn't sure exactly what you wanted to talk about this,

00:50:20   but I actually saw it and was thinking for you, as a dad, a dad of teenagers as well especially,

00:50:30   what do you think about the Apple Watch as a device for kids?

00:50:36   I know we're touching the third rail of podcasting now, we're just talking about parenting,

00:50:42   so I won't mind if you decide to rip cord and parachute right out of this conversation.

00:50:47   But do you have any thoughts on this as, like, what you think of the Apple Watch as a device for kids,

00:50:53   and/or what you would want feature-wise the device to have to be a good device for kids?

00:50:58   I don't have any first-hand experience with the Apple Watch school time features, right?

00:51:03   They rolled out a few years ago. I know Marco talked about it at length on ATP a couple of times,

00:51:07   and it seemed pretty buggy, and now I think they just have, like, a dummy phone set up for their son's watch. Crazy.

00:51:14   So I don't have experience with the software side of it, but from the hardware side of it,

00:51:19   like, if this makes the watch more durable, cheaper, and lighter weight, those are all three great things

00:51:26   if you're going to put a watch on a kid, or even if you just want to buy a watch yourself.

00:51:30   Like, I think what's most interesting about this rumor to me is not the kid angle,

00:51:35   but it's the more diversification of the Apple Watch line in ways that we haven't seen before.

00:51:42   You know, we have the SE, which diversifies and lowers the price, but to your point, Mike,

00:51:47   it does that by cutting features and giving you old stuff.

00:51:50   And this would probably still be true in this version, but it would be the first time they've moved downstream

00:51:57   or downmarket in terms of the build and the materials, right?

00:52:04   They've had ceramic, they've had titanium, they had actual, literal gold in the beginning that people try to forget about,

00:52:11   but they've never kind of gone the other way.

00:52:14   And so, yeah, I think it would be great if you are putting an Apple Watch on a kid,

00:52:18   but if you're not, you're just looking for a more affordable watch that maybe is in fun colors,

00:52:26   like if a boy can dream, then this is interesting to me through those lenses.

00:52:31   I can imagine the benefit, the thought of why an Apple Watch could be good for a kid, right? Because it's not a phone.

00:52:41   If you don't want to give them a phone, but you can contact them, they can contact you and Find My would work if it was cellular.

00:52:49   But yeah, it's an interesting, I don't know, it's an interesting idea.

00:52:56   The idea of making, see, here's my thing about this though.

00:53:02   It seems weird to me in a way to be like, "Hey, we made this Apple Watch for kids."

00:53:07   It's like, "Okay, thank you, it's expensive."

00:53:13   Is there anything, did you do anything other than make it out of plastic? I don't know.

00:53:19   Yeah, I think if they do this, the price has to come down more. That is a huge knock against the SE,

00:53:26   at least in its original design is that it wasn't that much cheaper, right? They haven't really gone down to where-

00:53:36   They brought it down a bit, it's 250 now. I think when it started, it was 300.

00:53:41   It's 199, 179. If they can get down there, I don't know if this is enough to do that, but boy, that's intriguing to a whole new section of potential buyers.

00:53:55   I love my Apple Watch Ultra and I plan on going to the Ultra 3 this year. I'm on the original Ultra now.

00:54:03   If they made fun color plastic watches, that's really interesting. I think people would be intrigued by that.

00:54:11   I just found a whole page on Apple's website called Apple Watch for your kids.

00:54:17   Oh, is it creepy?

00:54:19   It's actually quite attractive. They use really good illustration. I think it's a very different illustration,

00:54:26   but it's talking about what the benefits are for them and for you. It's a pretty nice web page.

00:54:33   I would be really intrigued if people have set this up, what they don't like about it.

00:54:38   Yeah, let us know in the feedback form if you've gone down this road. I'll say in our household,

00:54:43   both my high schoolers have iPhones now. Our daughter wears a Fitbit.

00:54:49   And I talked to her. I was like, if you want an Apple Watch, like because she is running track and doing soccer,

00:54:56   like lots of stuff, and she wanted it for the. Like the workout tracking and athletic stuff,

00:55:03   she didn't care about the notifications or anything. I think I think last time I looked through it,

00:55:07   she had a question about something and I looked at the Fitbit app with her like she's all the notifications off.

00:55:12   I'm so proud of you. You don't have any notifications on your wrist,

00:55:15   but she wanted a Fitbit in part because it was more durable and cheaper and it was a gift, you know,

00:55:22   but she was like, I don't, you know, I don't just spend that kind of money.

00:55:26   And she liked that the Fitbit was smaller and lighter and seemingly more resilient damage.

00:55:32   Does it have a screen? It has. I'm trying to I was trying to look on the Fitbit website.

00:55:37   She has the it's not one of the Apple Watch.

00:55:41   It's the Fitbit Charge 6 or maybe she has the five. So it has a screen, but it's in the band.

00:55:47   It's not like it doesn't look like a like a Apple Watch knockoff.

00:55:51   Like I mean, this kind of looks like if the Nike Fuel band continued. Yes.

00:55:55   Yes. Oh man. Rest in peace. That thing is awesome.

00:56:00   And again, this all makes me want an Apple Watch. That's not a watch.

00:56:03   Like just give me a fitness band so I can wear a regular watch on my other wrist,

00:56:07   but never going to happen as much as we want it. I don't think it will.

00:56:10   Maybe they'll do a ring and I'll be a ring person.

00:56:14   I don't know, man. Everyone that I've spoken to that has tried. Well, I was talking to Austin Evans.

00:56:19   So one person. He's not even a professional.

00:56:22   He's someone who I spoke to. I've seen videos from other people,

00:56:25   but he's someone who has been wearing these rings and they're just like, they're just not good.

00:56:30   It was really inaccurate. Like horrifically inaccurate.

00:56:33   I tried the Orr ring. Did you? Like a year ago. Yeah.

00:56:38   It was weird. Yeah. I don't like them. They're too big.

00:56:43   Like they're just too big. Chunky, chunky boys. I mean, my wedding band is tattooed on.

00:56:46   So any rings are weird to me now, but that's true. You know, maybe some sort of implant.

00:56:52   Straight in the chest. Would you want a ring Federico? A fitness ring?

00:56:58   I mean, I have an Apple Watch and I got, you know, I, I, I have actually nice looking rings.

00:57:04   Yeah. Where you do know. Yeah, no. So no.

00:57:09   I mean, if it doesn't do anything better or different from the Apple Watch, I'm just going to keep my Apple Watch, you know, that's fair.

00:57:17   Yeah.

00:57:20   This episode of connected is brought to you by express VPN.

00:57:24   Watching Netflix without using expressive opinion is like paying for a gym membership, but then only being allowed to use the treadmill.

00:57:31   That's where expressive opinion comes in. When you're using it, you can change your online location, which can change where streaming services think you're located.

00:57:40   And they have almost 100 different server locations so you can discover thousands of new shows to watch on Netflix, Disney plus BBC, I play or YouTube and more.

00:57:50   And there's loads of reasons to use expressive opinion over other options.

00:57:53   It's easy to use. Just fire up the app and click one button to change locations.

00:57:58   They're blazing fast speeds mean you can stream an HD with zero buffering and is compatible with all your devices, phones, laptops, smart TVs and more.

00:58:08   And expressive opinion has the added benefit of encrypting your data so you can browse the web more securely.

00:58:15   That means that I can watch something like Sherlock on a French Netflix or friends, which is on Netflix in the UK right now.

00:58:21   Just by opening the app, selecting the right location and tapping one button to connect and then refreshing the page to get access.

00:58:29   So make a smart choice. Stop paying full price for streaming services and only getting access to a fraction of their content.

00:58:36   Get your money's worth at express VPN dot com slash connected.

00:58:41   That's express VPN dot com slash connected to get an extra three months of express VPN for free.

00:58:49   Our thanks to express VPN for the support of the show and all of relay.

00:58:55   Beta check in time. We've got now two tracks.

00:58:59   IOS 18 Beta five is out and then happened.

00:59:05   18.1 has not received any updates, which is weird.

00:59:08   We'll get to that first in 18.0 betas. Mike, you talked about.

00:59:14   In dark mode, you can have dark mode with light icons.

00:59:19   There was something that you want to do. It's confusing.

00:59:22   Let's do it again. Originally it did what I want and then they changed it that if you had if you wanted to use dark mode, it forced you to have dark icons.

00:59:34   Now, actually, in beta four and of 18 and in beta one of 18.1,

00:59:41   Pranjay wrote into let us know and I'm very happy about this. You can do it.

00:59:45   You can change this again so you can have dark mode on or off on your devices.

00:59:50   It doesn't matter. It doesn't have to change your whether you use light icons or dark icons.

00:59:55   So I now have dark mode on with light icons.

00:59:59   But what's really funny is whenever I search for an app, they're always in dark icons.

01:00:04   That seems like a bug. Yes, it's definitely a bug. It's just funny to me.

01:00:08   But yes, so I am happy about that now. Widgets by default show dark.

01:00:14   But I can get by with that. The icons are more important to me because by and large, I don't like Apple's dark icons.

01:00:21   And so and also that some of the third party apps that I've seen that have dark mode tinting on their icons.

01:00:28   I don't like that either. I want to be able to just like I've always done choose my icons where I have choice.

01:00:35   And so I prefer to have that rather than the system just making a blanket switch for me.

01:00:40   But yes, so beta 5 is now out. There is no beta 2 of 18.1.

01:00:47   So the bad scenario that we were talking about with John last week has happened.

01:00:53   And so now I'm expecting Federico has done this. We'll get to that in a minute maybe.

01:00:59   If you're doing a review, you kind of have to go back now because we have no idea if or when.

01:01:04   It is super weird to me that we have this. I'll actually listen to Mike wrote in to say,

01:01:10   unless something changes around Apple intelligence, wouldn't we be looking at a future where there is two versions of every release?

01:01:16   Since AI is only supported on the newer phones, wouldn't it be true until they drop support for the other phones?

01:01:22   And this is an interesting question, but I think the answer to this is no.

01:01:26   Like the scenario where we have this 18.1 beta is just because they are trying to get these features ready for October and they want more time with it.

01:01:38   There are untold amount of feature flags that are turned on and off in like, say, for an iPad OS, right?

01:01:46   There are some devices that have run iPad OS 18 beta 5 or whatever, but they don't have stage manager.

01:01:54   They don't need separate versions of iOS for that to occur.

01:01:58   So like going into the future, when it comes to iOS 19, they're not going to need to have two versions of 19.

01:02:05   One that has Apple intelligence and one that doesn't because they're just able to, as we spoke about, as we assumed and is the case with Federico,

01:02:13   they just lock him out of being able to get those features. But it's still technically in the operating system.

01:02:18   He just can't turn them on. So I don't think that this will be a thing that we get forever.

01:02:24   But it is super strange to have currently two versions of the same operating system on different betas concurrently.

01:02:36   And now the features have diverged and I guess it is not clear now to understand when those features will merge again.

01:02:47   Right. Right. We're going to talk about the photos changes in a minute. Those are in 18.0 beta 5, not an 18.1.

01:02:55   There is also bugs in 18.0 and 18.1 that are different. It's very strange.

01:03:04   And like so right now. I have one phone on 18.0 beta 5 and my carry phones on 18.1.

01:03:12   And it's like it's a mess. Like I really thought 18.1 would be in lockstep with the changes in 18.0.

01:03:20   It's just like plus Apple intelligence thrown in on top. But it doesn't seem to be what they're doing.

01:03:25   At least of this recording. Maybe in a couple of days we'll know more. But it's weird for now.

01:03:31   Federico, can you tell us about those photo changes? Yeah. So I was really surprised by this.

01:03:38   We spoke about the photos we designed before and how after an initial shock, we kind of, you know, especially Mike and I,

01:03:47   we really liked where Apple was going, you know, with the sort of half view of your recent photos and then the collections below and the customization and the carousel at the top that allowed you to pin different collections and swipe between them in the carousel.

01:04:03   Well, so the carousel is gone. And that's the thing that makes me really sad because it was probably my favorite feature of the redesign. And now it's just been removed.

01:04:15   I'm happy that at least this was kind of like a good news bad news thing for me when I saw the headline. I just thought that they got rid of all of it.

01:04:26   But like they still have the split screen. But there's just no carousel at the top. And while I did like that, the thing I liked most was just having the split screen where you've got, you can get to your images if you want to, but you can also get to all the other stuff way faster.

01:04:43   But it's a shame to me because I really liked how customizable everything was. And I don't really understand what this deals with, but they obviously have had enough feedback about it that they wanted to change it.

01:05:05   Yeah, and it seems like the grid now takes slightly more space than before on the page. And you have to wonder if they listen to this criticism enough, how far down can you push the grid until you revert to your original design?

01:05:23   Right now it still covers, I would say 70% of the screen. It used to be more like 60%. It used to be less. And now the grid is more prominent. But you can still see your pin collections and your recent days. You just have to scroll a little bit more.

01:05:42   Actually, no, you can see your recent days and your people and pets.

01:05:45   Yeah, but of course you can change those around in order.

01:05:48   You can change those around.

01:05:50   I would be really surprised if there were any more significant changes here. I feel like they've made this change and now they'll push this. This will be it.

01:06:02   Yeah, but yeah, that's what they've done with photos. I continue to be a fan of the new design and especially the recent days is really the thing that does it for me. The categorization of photos by day while removing. Although it doesn't always do a perfect job.

01:06:21   And this is probably because my phone is indexing everything again because I had to downgrade, which was a horrific experience that I don't wish on anybody.

01:06:32   But still, so for example, right now my recent days, it's not doing the best job because it's showing me a screenshot, for example, under yesterday.

01:06:42   And I bet it'll soon be gone as soon as the more indexing is done on the device. Just a matter of time. But yeah, I think this is the version of photos that is shipping and I continue to be a fan.

01:06:55   Despite the fact that I really like the carousel and swiping from my recent photos to my favorites. And now that's no longer possible, but maybe someday it'll come back.

01:07:08   And then there's a new feature in beta 5 called, what is it, distraction control in Safari?

01:07:18   Yeah.

01:07:20   What is this? Can you explain this feature? And so I've also seen people refer to this as like a surprise. Has this not been mentioned before now?

01:07:31   It was rumored that Apple was going to work on a way to let you remove like ads and other distracting elements from websites.

01:07:39   You've helped me because I saw, I was reading a MacRumors article in the show and it's got a video too that shows how it works.

01:07:46   And they're like, this is a surprise feature. And I was like, but I knew about this. And I was looking through Apple's like preview and couldn't find anything.

01:07:53   But that you've now reminded me what I knew, which was the rumor.

01:07:56   Yeah. So the idea is that you have this feature on the Mac, iOS and iPadOS to hide distracting items.

01:08:06   Such as Apple mentions like signing banners or content overlays. Like, I don't know, the boxes that get you to sign up for a newsletter, for example.

01:08:17   You go to the page menu, the page menu being like the place where everything is like stuffed into now. Like reader, website settings, like all that. It's called the page menu.

01:08:30   So you go there, you tap on hide distracting elements. And the first time you do it, the system tells you that it's not like a permanent ad removal.

01:08:45   So this is the thing that Apple is doing. Like they tell you this is not a way to permanently remove ads or other areas that frequently change content.

01:08:59   Apple is saying that basically this is a way for you to hide static elements that you just don't like on websites.

01:09:09   But if those elements change on a regular basis, they're still going to show them to you.

01:09:15   So this is Apple basically trying to circumvent the discussion regarding, well, do you hate web publishers now?

01:09:24   Because you get people to hide advertisements and banners from websites.

01:09:28   Therefore, helping people, you know, therefore helping people, you know, not seeing the ads and those publishers suffering because of the feature that you have built in the browser used by hundreds of millions of people.

01:09:41   Like they're trying to sidestep that controversy by saying, well, we don't block ads.

01:09:47   We just let you hide distracting elements that don't change often.

01:09:51   But if they do, we're going to show them to you because maybe it's an ad and the publisher needs to make money.

01:09:56   We don't want, they're saying, we don't want to be in any capacity.

01:10:01   We don't want to be in this business of content blocking.

01:10:04   We just want to have you, we just want to make you have a nicer, more pleasant experience with Safari by hiding things you dislike as long as they don't change on a regular basis.

01:10:17   Now, I think it's a clever approach to sidestep that controversy, but I still have concerns because like a site like Mac Stories, for example, we are, or Daring Fireball for that matter,

01:10:34   we have a single ad that changes usually on a weekly basis.

01:10:40   Now, if you try now and you hide that ad, that's gone forever.

01:10:47   If you refresh the page, it's gone.

01:10:50   That's because it's not a Google ad that changes on every page reload or every day or I don't even know how Google ads work these days, honestly.

01:11:00   You are permanently hiding a source of income for us.

01:11:05   What if you change the ad banner though?

01:11:08   What happens then, do you know?

01:11:10   Well, I guess we'll find out on Monday.

01:11:12   Oh, okay. You don't know because you haven't done it yet. That makes sense.

01:11:17   Yeah. So, I don't know.

01:11:21   Mostly, and this is like my sentiment with everything on iOS, I am very ambivalent about iOS and iPadOS this year.

01:11:33   And this is actually what I wrote in my introduction for the iOS review.

01:11:38   I am, for the first time in, really since I started doing this, I have never been so ambivalent about an annual iOS release.

01:11:47   Mostly I'm thinking, did you have to do this?

01:11:51   Like, was it absolutely necessary?

01:11:53   Like, are people out there thinking, I'm using Apple's browser and it's not a pleasant experience?

01:12:00   Or like, are they thinking about the web?

01:12:03   And maybe if they are having those thoughts, they also know that they can go to the App Store and download a third-party content blocker.

01:12:10   Like, are there people out there saying, man, I wish that Apple let me hide DOM elements on web pages via HTML because I dislike them.

01:12:21   Like, it just seems, and especially with all these conversations that we're seeing this year with publishers, smaller publishers suffering because of changes to Google search and AI.

01:12:34   Read the room, you know? Like, was it necessary to ship this feature?

01:12:40   Like, it just seems, as with many things on iOS these days, a little out of touch.

01:12:48   But that's just my opinion.

01:12:50   It's got a beautiful animation, I'll give you that.

01:12:52   It's very nicely done.

01:12:54   It's out of touch with some people.

01:12:57   But here's my thing. I haven't used this feature, but I've seen videos of it, right?

01:13:01   The thing that I find weird about it is like, they didn't really commit.

01:13:08   Like, I was on the web today and I was reading an article on Variety, right?

01:13:14   And as I was scrolling, there were videos popping up, there were different weird banners made with AI art all over the place.

01:13:26   And it was a not good experience to read the article.

01:13:29   So what I do in these scenarios is I just turn on reader mode and I read it in reader.

01:13:35   But if I was on this webpage and I was being frustrated by this, and I'd be like, "Great, I'm going to deal with the distractions.

01:13:44   Alright, so now I've got to play this game for a minute where I tap on a bunch of areas of the article before I start reading."

01:13:51   Like, I just don't understand this feature.

01:13:54   And why would I not just use reader instead?

01:13:58   Why would I sit and press all these buttons?

01:14:02   And so it's what you're saying. It's like they were like, "Oh, we're going to give people a way to block ads, but we don't actually want to do that, so we're going to do this."

01:14:14   And so I'm kind of just like, "Why did you do this then?"

01:14:18   Like, why did you do this? Because you kind of, it doesn't make any, I don't think this makes anybody happy.

01:14:24   And I can't really imagine a lot of people using this feature because you kind of have to set up this webpage that you're going to read and then close the tab.

01:14:34   Like, it's weird. It just seems very strange to me as a feature to have.

01:14:40   But maybe it is me that is out of touch and people want to play this like, Safari hidden distractions game every time they go to a webpage.

01:14:50   But I know I certainly don't and so I find other ways of getting around content like this.

01:14:57   And let me tell you, I feel for Stephen in this scenario because these kinds of things, it's what generates so much support email to people.

01:15:07   Where they're like, "Hey, I can't see this thing!"

01:15:10   It's like, "Do you have a content blocker turned on?"

01:15:12   And this is just another one of those.

01:15:14   Like, "Did you hide this element?"

01:15:17   Yeah, it's nine times out of ten, someone's like, "I can't sign up for membership."

01:15:23   "Turn content blockers off on the website."

01:15:25   And we've done some things to try to work around that, but it is, it's always something.

01:15:30   I agree with you, Mike. It feels like Apple wanted to dip their toe into water with the feature here.

01:15:35   But also in my mind, like I'm not sure how it stacks up compared to like, well, they gave us years ago,

01:15:42   they gave us the ability for developers to build and for users to use actual ad blockers in their browser,

01:15:50   which are automatically removing these things as opposed to the user manually doing them.

01:15:55   So I don't know if it's a huge death blow to online advertising, but it's definitely another step in that direction.

01:16:04   I don't think it's a, honestly I don't think it's a blow at all.

01:16:08   But this is kind of what I'm getting at. I don't really understand what this is for, really.

01:16:15   But it does lean into something that I've found frustrating about Apple over the years,

01:16:22   maybe over the last five years, of them feeling this need to get involved.

01:16:29   So this is like, app tracking transparency, which is a thing that I still to this day do not agree with.

01:16:36   I don't think that it is a well designed or implemented system,

01:16:40   and it hasn't actually done anything to help what Apple set out to want to help, realistically.

01:16:46   Because if you see it as what it was, which was we want to get money out of Meta,

01:16:52   Meta's just worked it out on their own. They're fine.

01:16:55   And then stuff like, if you use Apple's Mail app, it doesn't report open rates and information like that anymore to email publishers.

01:17:04   And email targeting platforms and stuff like that. Why did they need to do this?

01:17:11   What is the need to harm people who are trying to run their small businesses?

01:17:17   When I think people don't, who cares about if a brand that sends you an email knows you opened it?

01:17:26   Or just knows it was opened. Not even who, but just knows it was opened.

01:17:30   Who cares about that? Were people calling out for that?

01:17:33   But no, Apple decided that they wanted to make that harder for people that work in consumer brands.

01:17:39   Just a lot of this stuff, it's like, I don't understand what they're going for here.

01:17:48   And it's like this kind of Caped Crusader kind of mentality, where they're saving us from ourselves.

01:17:54   Which is also super funny, but the next thing that we're going to talk about.

01:17:57   Yeah, there's some irony this on the next topic. It's also a feature that doesn't work very well.

01:18:05   Someone in the Discord she put in showing it working on Mac stories and it blocks the ad and the navigation.

01:18:12   It doesn't see those different elements.

01:18:14   And I would imagine that the Mac stories website is built well enough that it should know those are different things.

01:18:20   It's kind of goofy. Not good.

01:18:25   Well, there's that.

01:18:29   Got to redesign Mac stories, you know?

01:18:32   Well, that's a different topic, but yes.

01:18:36   This episode of Connected is brought to you by ZOJO.

01:18:40   ZOJO offers a powerful cross-platform development environment.

01:18:45   Perfect for Apple enthusiasts looking to create their own applications without the complexity of any other coding language.

01:18:51   You can quickly create and release applications with it for Mac and iOS.

01:18:56   Which means you can reach millions of users using a single programming language with an intuitive IDE.

01:19:02   Complete with drag and drop interface building capabilities.

01:19:05   And Connected listeners, who we all know are passionate technology users, will love the intuitive interface and rapid development capabilities of ZOJO.

01:19:15   ZOJO is a free download for development and testing and Connected listeners can take 15% off any license with the coupon code CON24.

01:19:26   It's all capital, CON24.

01:19:30   That 15% discount is available through October of this year.

01:19:34   Just go to ZOJO. That's X-O-J-O. ZOJO.com/connected.

01:19:41   That's 15% off any ZOJO license with the coupon code CON24 through October 2024.

01:19:48   The link, all the details are in the show notes.

01:19:50   And our thanks to ZOJO for their support of the show.

01:19:53   We're going to finish today's episode talking about a ruling that came down in the US this week.

01:20:04   That Google is a monopoly.

01:20:07   This has been ongoing in the US for a while.

01:20:12   And of course, we have a link to The Verge, but also to One True John's article talking about what this means and what comes next.

01:20:23   The headline for people in our neck of the woods is that Google paying to be the default search engine in browsers is not going to be allowed.

01:20:38   And that if this all is upheld.

01:20:42   That's obviously going to have some pretty wild knock-on effects in the world.

01:20:46   Apple being one of them, Mozilla being another.

01:20:49   I think Mozilla is probably in real trouble because the Google deal to have Google in Firefox as the default browser is the majority of Mozilla's income.

01:20:59   Which is not great for them.

01:21:02   But what do you all think about this and what do we think it means for Apple's services business?

01:21:07   Well, this is the interesting thing.

01:21:11   I'm intrigued to see, really I've only focused on how this Google thing affects Apple.

01:21:18   But I'm sure that there are much bigger effects.

01:21:21   Because this is ruling that Google is using its power in a variety of ways.

01:21:26   It would be intriguing to see as more people tease this apart.

01:21:30   Because the judge hasn't really, for what I've seen, the judge hasn't said what's going to happen here.

01:21:37   It's just like, alright, you are a monopoly and now we're going to start unwinding some of this stuff.

01:21:42   Obviously, after Google appeals it, blah blah blah blah blah.

01:21:46   But this is super interesting considering Apple and their services revenue and the previous earnings.

01:21:55   Services continues to grow and it is like the shining beacon for Apple.

01:22:04   And they keep talking about it and they keep talking about it more.

01:22:07   It's the biggest headline of their earnings report is that the services went up again and they're so happy about it.

01:22:14   And the growth is going to continue because I don't think, I mean we don't know.

01:22:20   But I can't imagine that Apple's services growth was coming from Google.

01:22:25   It felt like this was a fixed thing that they would receive every year.

01:22:29   Maybe it would go up every year.

01:22:31   So unless Apple was doing some interesting accounting as to how they would play that out through the year.

01:22:36   I think what's going to happen is if this does finish, this does go away.

01:22:42   Apple will have a year where they are down year over year.

01:22:49   Every single quarter most likely in their services revenue.

01:22:54   Yeah, it seems like Google's payments are maybe 20 to 25% of services revenue.

01:22:59   So at Apple's growth pace they would make up that difference.

01:23:05   But it would be a blow in terms of this thing has grown for years and years and years basically unstopped.

01:23:14   And that would obviously take a step back.

01:23:17   So it would hurt their services revenue.

01:23:19   It will crush their stock.

01:23:22   The stock, yes it will.

01:23:23   Yeah.

01:23:24   Which is, and that's the reason that the services thing existed in the first place.

01:23:29   So it's going to be interesting for them to deal with that.

01:23:33   Wall Street, more like Fall Street, am I right?

01:23:36   Sure.

01:23:37   Especially at the moment.

01:23:38   Don't look at your 401k.

01:23:40   But let's just take as read that this will happen.

01:23:46   That this services revenue from Google is going to go away.

01:23:50   The question is what does Apple do?

01:23:52   And from what I can surmise and from what I've read and John had a good piece about this in Mac stories.

01:23:59   They kind of have like three options.

01:24:02   They either take a deal like this from someone else, which is hilarious to me that that is still a thing that could happen.

01:24:08   But someone else can still do this.

01:24:10   Like if you're not considered powerful enough, these deals aren't necessarily illegal.

01:24:15   I don't think they would.

01:24:16   I mean, Eddie Q said Microsoft could offer them the company and they still wouldn't make Bing the default.

01:24:21   This is savage.

01:24:22   One of the great quotes.

01:24:23   So the full quote is, "I don't believe there is a price in the world that Microsoft could offer us.

01:24:27   They offered to give us Bing for free.

01:24:29   They could give us the whole company."

01:24:31   And this was from the discovery in this case.

01:24:34   Like that is a thing that Eddie said in an email, I think.

01:24:36   Just love Eddie Q, man.

01:24:38   What a guy.

01:24:39   So they could do it, but they could, right?

01:24:41   They could take money from Bing.

01:24:42   They could if they wanted to.

01:24:43   They could stick as is where Google will be the default because let's be realistic here.

01:24:50   That is what users want.

01:24:51   And three, they could create their own search engine and their own ad business to make up this money.

01:24:57   What do you think is the most likely?

01:25:00   I'm interested in what you two think.

01:25:01   What do you think is the most likely scenario here in a world where Google is no longer paying Apple for the default?

01:25:09   They take the money from somebody else.

01:25:11   Oh, who?

01:25:13   I don't know.

01:25:17   Okay, no, I'm going to say it actually.

01:25:20   They take the money from some kind of AI-based search engine, maybe even the open AI.

01:25:27   Well, they have one now.

01:25:28   Search GPT.

01:25:30   Yeah.

01:25:31   So maybe it is.

01:25:32   I still think they take the money from somebody else because they love money.

01:25:36   And $20 billion going away from that services revenue, that's going to sting, man.

01:25:41   Yeah.

01:25:42   I think they're going to take the money from somebody else.

01:25:45   Well, what I'll say is they do love money.

01:25:48   I know it would be incredibly difficult, but they could do it themselves.

01:25:51   They have a lot of the parts now.

01:25:53   It would be hard because I actually think the hard part would be the ads part, but they have the --

01:26:01   Apple have the ability if they wanted to to do -- well, then are they not just going to get smashed in the same way that Google just did?

01:26:09   Probably.

01:26:10   I mean, eventually.

01:26:11   So they would set this thing up and then everyone would be like, "You can't do that."

01:26:15   And realistically, when you think about it, they probably shouldn't be able to do that.

01:26:19   They're just like, "Hey, we're going to make you use our search engine instead."

01:26:24   Yeah, probably a bad look.

01:26:26   My guess is that if they don't like this money from Google anymore is that they put up some sort of search engine ballot.

01:26:37   Like they would be probably forced to do at some point in the EU and just let people pick.

01:26:43   So Google is not the default anymore.

01:26:46   I think if it's your default now, that continues, but in new installations, when you open Safari, you pick between Google and Bing and Perplexity and search GPT or whatever else.

01:26:58   But they get no money, though.

01:27:00   But they get no money, so they just put Google on a list with a bunch of lesser companies and let the user decide.

01:27:06   And everyone picks Google.

01:27:08   That's the thing, and they talked about this on Dithering the other day.

01:27:11   Part of antitrust, and I'm definitely not a lawyer, but part of it looks at consumer harm.

01:27:18   And that is a hard thing for me to get my head around with this.

01:27:24   Like, Google is the best. They've been the best for a long time.

01:27:27   Yes, they probably shouldn't pay Apple all that money, and definitely, yes, Apple shouldn't accept all that money.

01:27:33   But if Google's not the default, most people are still going to pick it because it is the best.

01:27:40   And it's the most well-known.

01:27:42   And I don't feel like I'm being harmed by any of this.

01:27:47   Maybe that's just me. Maybe it's naive.

01:27:49   But I think Apple and Google are going to be just fine without this deal in place.

01:27:55   I don't think Google's going to suddenly see a massive exodus of iPhone users going to their competitors because they're not paying for those users anymore.

01:28:04   The funny thing is Google wins big time.

01:28:06   They don't have to give any of this money away, and they're not going to lose user share.

01:28:10   They're definitely not going to lose $20 billion a year worth of user share.

01:28:14   They're not going to lose user share. I mean, let's be realistic.

01:28:17   Are you two looking to switch away from Google search anytime soon?

01:28:21   No.

01:28:22   And we're informed users, right?

01:28:25   So the average user's not going to be like, "Oh, man, let me go get my Kagi on."

01:28:29   It's just not happening.

01:28:31   People want to use Google, and there's a reason for this.

01:28:34   This is the funny thing. This situation has not caused user harm. It hasn't.

01:28:40   But it shouldn't have existed. It's wrong, in my opinion.

01:28:44   That Google can just do this.

01:28:47   People can choose whoever they want.

01:28:52   But this deal has just felt gross to me.

01:28:55   Really, it's felt gross on Apple's side more than on Google's side because there is this thing.

01:29:01   The company that we previously spoke about putting app tracking transparency in place, right?

01:29:06   Or you shouldn't be tracked across apps.

01:29:09   But we'll allow Google to give us money so we will encourage you to use Google.

01:29:15   And then, "Well, whatever happens out there on Google, I don't know, man.

01:29:19   We can't control that." We don't know.

01:29:21   That's always felt wrong. I don't like the fact that this happened.

01:29:25   But I agree. I don't think that it is of any ill effect to users because people want to use Google.

01:29:36   And please, I beg you, do not send in feedback telling me that you use a separate search engine.

01:29:42   I'm sure you do, but you know what I'm saying, right?

01:29:46   Google is used by everybody in the world, essentially.

01:29:50   And the amount of people that aren't using Google is so small compared to everybody that is.

01:29:57   It's the verb for searching on the web.

01:30:01   That only happens in very specific scenarios.

01:30:05   And Google is one of the very small amount of companies that will ever exist that their product becomes a verb.

01:30:12   And there's a very good reason for that.

01:30:13   Oh yeah, that's a huge deal. And I just don't think consumers are going to suddenly be wanting to move away from Google because this deal falls through.

01:30:25   And I think people who are already using Unalternative like DuckDuckGo, what's the paid one that some people like?

01:30:31   Kagi. Kagi is the one I just made a joke about.

01:30:35   Because it's like, "Oh no, but it doesn't make..."

01:30:37   Like, if you don't, why would you remember that brand?

01:30:39   Exactly.

01:30:40   It's just like it is what it is, right?

01:30:42   Yeah.

01:30:43   And those people who are already using those, I just... I don't know.

01:30:46   This is an interesting decision. I think it's going to take a long time to iron it all out.

01:30:52   And I think the 20 billion Google pays Apple, while interesting to us, is, to a point Mike made earlier, only a small part of this case.

01:31:01   And there's going to be lots of other things that have to be sorted out because of this.

01:31:08   But it's a big day for antitrust in the United States because at least the last couple of years, the US government has actually not been very successful in these cases.

01:31:18   And it's been a bit of a complaint about some of the staff and some of the leadership in these agencies that they haven't been effective.

01:31:26   And now they have a win, and it'll be interesting to see how that goes.

01:31:30   And it will be appealed, and it's going to take a long time.

01:31:33   But this sort of opens a new chapter in tech antitrust in the United States that we really haven't seen here, right?

01:31:41   There have been Congress people and everything that talked about, "Yes, we've got to regulate these companies."

01:31:47   Some people a few years ago wanted to break up Amazon between this Amazon.com and Amazon Web Services and their own in-house brand.

01:31:59   Lots of talk, but this is sort of the starting gun for what is potentially a very huge shakeup in consumer tech, at least in the US.

01:32:10   But we just don't know how it's going to look.

01:32:12   There is one lasting effect to Apple, though, that will remain. It's going to be very interesting to see, right?

01:32:18   So services, yeah, if services is growing, services will keep growing.

01:32:22   Apple's profit is going to take a massive hit that won't recover.

01:32:28   That's going to be a problem for them.

01:32:30   It does not take $20 billion a year to keep the default set in Safari, right?

01:32:35   That's just money they're being handed and putting in the bank.

01:32:39   Yes.

01:32:40   And so that is probably going to be about 20 to 25%, maybe, of I think would be down, if I'm doing my math correctly.

01:32:50   In 2023, a quarter of profit for Apple is $20 to $30 billion they make per quarter in profit.

01:33:02   And so it's basically wiping one of those out.

01:33:06   That's not going to just reappear, no matter what they do.

01:33:11   Because any scenario other than Federico's expected scenario of taking money from someone else,

01:33:16   but they're not going to make that much money from someone else.

01:33:18   No one else has got this kind of money except Microsoft.

01:33:21   And unless Microsoft funnel that money through OpenAI into Apple, it's not going to happen.

01:33:28   And I think Apple would be, I think it would also be a weird choice for Apple to take that money again.

01:33:34   But I think as Federico pointed out, they love money.

01:33:38   And so they would take it until they're told they can't take it anymore.

01:33:42   But it was interesting, up until we had this conversation, I was just like, "Oh, there's no way they're going to do this."

01:33:47   But I forgot about search GPT.

01:33:50   That feels possible.

01:33:54   It would be, hmm, it feels possible.

01:33:58   That could be an effect to Google.

01:34:00   Because I think over the next few years, I think people maybe wouldn't mind that.

01:34:09   Especially if people had like Chat GPT in our iPhones.

01:34:13   And so maybe they wouldn't mind so much about search GPT if they're so happy to get Chat GPT responses.

01:34:21   That is an interesting, that's interesting.

01:34:25   Time will tell. It could be a very interesting time in the Safari settings landscape.

01:34:30   Who knew? Who knew it could be so much fun?

01:34:34   I think that does it for this week. Federico, we're so glad you're back.

01:34:39   Thank you for returning from the beach.

01:34:42   Thank you for not staying.

01:34:45   I did it for you. Specifically for you, Steven.

01:34:48   That's so nice.

01:34:49   Yeah, yeah.

01:34:50   So nice of you.

01:34:51   If you want to find the links to the stories we spoke about, head on over to the website, relay.fm/connected/513.

01:34:59   There you can submit feedback or follow up.

01:35:03   You can also become a member and get Connected Pro, the longer ad-free version of the show each and every week.

01:35:08   Members of Relay shows also get access to a newsletter, some members-only podcasts, and a really awesome Discord server.

01:35:16   If you want to find more of us, we're around. Federico is the editor-in-chief of MacStories.net.

01:35:21   I know you all are hard at work on your coverage of the new OSes this fall.

01:35:26   I will say I greatly enjoyed App Stories this weekend about the new version of WatchOS, which I've paid no attention to.

01:35:34   I was like, "Oh, it does all sorts of cool things."

01:35:37   It's the most exciting OS release.

01:35:39   It may be. It could be.

01:35:42   You can find Federico on social media as viticiviticci@mastodonandthreads.

01:35:50   Mike is the co-host of a bunch of other shows here on Relay.

01:35:53   He's also--what is your title, a Cortex brand chief product officer?

01:35:58   Creative director.

01:36:00   Creative director and chief product officer.

01:36:04   No, get rid of that.

01:36:06   And?

01:36:07   Creative director.

01:36:08   Boss.

01:36:09   Co-founder. I'm co-founder here with you.

01:36:11   iPad user. I had a phone call today with a sponsor, and they needed to know my title, and I said, "Co-founder."

01:36:17   She goes, "Hmm. I just don't know what that meant."

01:36:20   Okay.

01:36:21   "Don't know what that means."

01:36:23   They were a big company in this, and maybe they think co-founder is like a hippie or a hipster.

01:36:27   Every company has a founder.

01:36:30   They thought you were like Steve Wozniak or something.

01:36:34   It could be.

01:36:36   I probably know more about performers than Woz does at this point, though.

01:36:40   That wouldn't be surprising, though, would it?

01:36:44   I mean, it's not really a high bar, you know?

01:36:47   At this point, does anybody know more about performers than you?

01:36:51   Probably not.

01:36:52   Probably not.

01:36:54   Except for the fine readers of 512pixels.net, you know?

01:36:57   That's right.

01:36:58   They're going to get there. We're all coming along for the journey with you.

01:37:00   Please subscribe.

01:37:03   You can find Mike as I-M-Y-K-E on Mastodon and Threads.

01:37:09   You can find my writing at 512pixels.net.

01:37:12   We've been making fun of it all episode, apparently.

01:37:15   And I also co-host Mac Power Users, which comes out on Sundays here on Relay.

01:37:20   You can find me as ismh86 on Threads and Mastodon.

01:37:25   I'd like to thank our sponsors this week for making this show possible,

01:37:28   NetSuite, Fitbot, ExpressVPN, and ZOJO.

01:37:32   I'd like to thank our members who support us.

01:37:34   Again, go check that out on the web.

01:37:36   And until next time, guys, say goodbye.

01:37:39   Arrivederci.

01:37:40   Cheerio.

01:37:41   Bye, y'all.